top of page

Does Your Fiction Villain Have to be a Tangible Person? 4 Elements to Include if They Aren't

Updated: Jul 10

Questioning Villainy

In the vast expanse of fantasy literature, there exists a perennial debate: does a villain have to be a tangible person, or can it be more of a force? This question, recently pondered within my critique group, sparked a fascination that led to this podcast episode. So, what's your take? Join me as we delve into the intricate realm of villains in fiction.

A Glimpse into Maxwell Alexander Drake's Perspective

Years ago, at a writing conference, I had the pleasure of listening to Maxwell Alexander Drake, a renowned fantasy author, discuss villains. Drake adamantly championed the idea that villains should be tangible, sentient beings, playing significant roles in the narrative. His stance resonated with many, but it also spurred contemplation on the nature of villainy in fantastical realms.

A black-hooded figure whose face you can't see (i.e. a villain) holds something white in his hands. The figure stands against a blue and orange background. To his left, white and yellow words read, "Does Your fiction villain have to be a tangible person? 4 Elements to include if they aren't." Above him in a blue oval, yellow words read, "Fiction Author Business School."

Does Your Villain Have to Be a Tangible Person?

The crux of the matter lies in whether a villain's essence must be embodied in a physical form or if its presence can transcend corporeal boundaries. While some argue for the former, citing the need for a palpable antagonist to anchor the story, others find solace in the nebulous, embracing the idea of a villainous force shaping events from the shadows.

Unpacking the Essence of Villainy

At its core, the effectiveness of a villain lies not in its tangibility but in the intricate web of emotions, motivations, and actions it weaves throughout the narrative. A villain, whether tangible or ethereal, must fulfill certain criteria to resonate with readers and propel the story forward.

Crafting a Compelling Villain: The Invisible Elements

Drawing parallels to baking, where ingredients blend to create a delectable treat, crafting a compelling villain requires a meticulous understanding of the invisible elements at play. Emotions, motivations, and psychological depth breathe life into the antagonist, transcending mere physicality.

The Villain's Presence: Tangible or Transcendent?

While the presence of a villain is undeniable, its manifestation need not adhere strictly to physical form. Through subtle cues, ominous undertones, and indirect encounters, authors can imbue their narratives with the palpable sense of villainy without resorting to overt exposition.

Navigating the Spectrum of Villainy

From Sauron's ominous influence in "The Lord of the Rings" to the ethereal force of "The Nothing" in "The NeverEnding Story," literature offers a spectrum of villainous manifestations. Regardless of form, what remains paramount is the villain's impact on characters and readers alike.

Embracing the Essence of Villainy

As writers, we wield the power to sculpt worlds and shape destinies, breathing life into characters both tangible and transcendent. In our quest for compelling narratives, let us not be bound by the constraints of physicality but instead embrace the boundless possibilities of villainy in all its forms.

So, does your fiction villain have to be a tangible person? Perhaps not. But what truly matters is the resonance they evoke, the emotions they stir, and the stories they inspire. Thank you for joining me on this journey through the enigmatic realm of fictional antagonists. Stay tuned for more insights into the craft of storytelling.

Join the 6 Figure Stories Facebook Group:

Apply for the 6 Figure Stories Beta here:

Follow or DM me on Instagram here:


Stuck on some part of your story or manuscript? Sign up for a free manuscript audit with me and I’ll help you get unstuck! Sign up here:


Get the Productivity Planner for Fiction Authors here: 

Join the Wait List for Fiction by Design here:


Get your copy of the Fiction Author Success Timeline Here:


Join the Advanced Waitlist for Fiction by Design here: 



5 Steps to Planning the Beginning, Middle, and End of Your Fiction Story:  

7 Ways to Sell Your Book Every Month Without Breaking the Bank:  

10 Plot-Thickening Events that Every Fiction Best Seller Includes:  


Leave me an audio review or recommend an episode on Speakpipe: 


(Where possible, I use affiliate links.)



Connect With Me on Social Media:

9 views0 comments


bottom of page